Where is Leo Schofield’s Wife Crissie Carter Now?

Michelle Saum Schofield’s death on February 24, 1987 has been more than 30 years ago. Unfortunately, many questions remain about her case. For the past five or so years, though, as profiled in ’20/20: Last Seen In Lakeland,’ the primary one has been if her husband Leo Schofield really killed her or if he’s serving time for another’s actions. But for now, if you simply wish to learn more about the one individual determined to always fight for his freedom — his second wife, Crissie Carter — we’ve got the necessary details for you.

Crissie Carter: Who are you?

Crissie, an ex-state probation officer, met Leo while she was teaching at the Hendry Correctional Institution in 1991. He soon became her favorite inmate and she was captivated by his story. As she helped convicts with their checkbook balances and resume writing, she observed that Leo was always honest about his innocence. Crissie was no exception. Crissie was the only person who actually returned home to look at all of the legal records. This led to a personal relationship and Crissie even stated she believed him.

This connection of theirs gradually evolved into a deep romance, and they blissfully ended up tying the knot at the chapel in DeSoto Correctional Institution in 1995 — Leo had been transferred. “My family was supportive, but not necessarily happy,” Crissie candidly revealed, referring to her loved ones’ reaction to her choice of a life partner. “I have friends that don’t talk to me anymore.” However, she has never let any of this affect her because she not only loves Leo but also trusts in his blamelessness with her whole heart; it’s why she began going down the legal route as well.

Crissie actually hired a new defense attorney for her husband in 2004, who quickly aided her years-long quest to get the previously unidentified fingerprints from Michelle’s car formally examined. The technology for this wasn’t available back in 1987, yet new developments confirmed a match to convicted murderer Jeremy Scott (on an unrelated 1988 matter) in December of the same year. But alas, despite their consistent efforts, this seemingly crucial piece of evidence (along with Jeremy’s confession and recantation) has not affected Leo’s legal case in any way, to his wife’s chagrin.

Crissie Carter is missing.

“A lot of people get involved [with Leo’s case] because they hear the story from me…,” Crissie Carter Schofield once said. “Then they meet Leo; there’s something about him, he’s special.” Therefore, it’s no surprise she continues to be her husband’s greatest advocate, especially through her work alongside organizations like The Innocence Project to one day get him exonerated.

We should mention that Crissie’s hard work is not just for Leo or for a sense of vindication; she vehemently maintains it’s also for Michelle and to get her what she believes would be true justice. “It doesn’t end with Leo getting out,” she stated. “This is Michelle’s story.” As for her personal standing, from what we can tell, Crissie currently resides around the Fort Myers area in Florida, where she proudly serves as a professional clinical social worker.

Read More: Where is Leo Schofield’s Dad Now?

Leave a Comment